Where, then, does that leave us—consumers of rips and restorations, seekers of “new fixed” editions and archival masters? Perhaps in a position of care. To seek out odd, neglected films is an act of curiosity; to restore them is an act of stewardship. Both acts require humility. We should approach old films with a willingness to preserve their accident and context as much as their formal elements. And we should be honest about the changes we make, not pretending that a “fixed” file is the same artifact your grandfather watched on a rainy Saturday night.