People argued whether the Nightmaretaker did better or worse when he was possessed. Some said the devil improved him—made him fearless, capable, merciful in an efficient, surgical way. Others maintained that the man had been better before: clumsy, persevering, painfully honest, and therefore capable of a deeper kind of solace. The truth was shard-like: the devil's presence made his work more effective, his relief more absolute, and his bargains more dangerous. He became, in the local lore, a figure who could not be easily loved or hated, only engaged with—cautiously, contractually.